Why True, Broad-based Economic Recovery Is Not Possible

  Less Bad Does Not Preclude Terrible
 
 
Many economic indicators have turned less-bad during the first half of 2009. Before this point, many indicators were heading toward supplanting the worst records in US economic history.
Less bad indicates that people perceived levels that were so terrible that the mass psychology said, "Things are so very bad that they cannot get much worse. If not the bottom, this must be near the bottom". This allowed bargain hunters to rationalize the buying of stocks. This also allowed consumers to shop for the things they passed up in fear over the prior several months. Consumer goods that were considered less necessary over recent months are now becoming near-necessary, thereby provoking consumers to initiate buying.
Investors and consumers are ignoring, in wide-eyed disbelieving ignorance and shock, the macro facts. A few relevant macro facts include the government's increasing and active meddling in corporate board membership and policy. The Federal deficit, the US Congress, and the Federal Reserve's policies are, in common vernacular, Out Of Control. TARP money is being more widely distributed across more industries and more corporations. For example, BAC's board -- not just its CEO -- are being actively forced to change. Several major insurance companies are appear willing to accept TARP funds. This, even after it is evident that the loss of control and short-term fix provided by TARP funds opens the corporate doorway to US government control.
The United States is sailing in totally uncharted waters while being steered by a government empowered unlike any before it and holding to pseudo-idealisms wholly different from any before in the US.

The naive willingness of insurance companies and additional banks to accept TARP funds indicates a fundamental breakdown and erosion of US capitalism and leadership of corporate America. In prior times, these same companies would be led by men who would automatically find non-government solutions to cash shortfalls and business downturns. They might consolidate into larger, stronger, more profitable entities. They might extend borrowing. They might sell equity. They would definitely scale back expenses. They would know that they need to survive and they would survive.
Who reading this essay has not had an economic setback, calculated how to survive, and then survived stronger than before problems arose?
Today weakened managements are terrified for their own personal survival. Therefore, on a one-by-one basis, they are throwing in the towel, getting theirs, and damning their organizations to an existence under fascistic Communism. And we used to believe that model could not exist. It can in the new America that is morphing from democracy and capitalism into this dark, unprofitable, uninspiring, nasty model.

In a short-sighted, fascistic mode, the US government is disposing of the US auto industry -- GM and Chrysler. This naive action is being taken for political and grandstanding reasons. It will mark the end of US industry since it will have unimaginable, rippling unintended consequences throughout the economy. The trite slogan "Buy American" which had some meaning over recent decades, will have little meaning -- or, at best, a new meaning.
Americans will produce -- and therefore only have a choice to buy -- American-made products whose American employees will work for foreign companies. An irony is that unions will eventually fail and fall by the wayside even after all the bonuses and handouts they are currently receiving. In the new American industries, workers will be "discouraged" and, in reality, unable to form substantive unions whereby they influence their wages, workloads, and schedules. Foreign companies care little for unions and establish work environments that obviate the need for them.

Today wise people invest from this realistic perspective. If wrong, the investing perspective can be adapted within a more optimistic context. However investing today while assuming the usual American return to prosperity will position an investor far out on a dead tree limb.
Add in to this mix the fact that the world's economic engine is changing in every meaningful aspect from capitalism to fascistic Communism. This is the unneeded -- the superfluous -- final nail in the American economy's coffin.

An optimistic person will realize that fortunes are often made during difficult economic phases. But often the fortune earner must be more smart, more tenacious, and more hard-working than the fortune grabbers fortunate enough to thrive during the easy phases.